You are here: Home » Heroes » Horse Trapped in Stall for Most of His Life Learns to Trust Again.

Horse Trapped in Stall for Most of His Life Learns to Trust Again.

 The first step out of the stall was the most challenging for Monty.
Monty was completely mistreated and locked in a dirty stall for several years. He was terrified and did not understand was taking place when given the opportunity to walk out of his prison. Monty was reluctant and frightened to leave his compound, where the only attention he ever received was when his owner tossed some food, hay or water in his area. He has no friends and did not know the warmth of love.

Monty had been trapped in his stall for so long, Travis and others did not have any idea what to expect when they opened his gate.


Monty was one of many mistreated animals found on a ten acre property in Scottsdale, Arizona , neary two years ago. Trisha Houlihan, founder and executive director of Saving Paws Rescue, AZ of Phoenix, had become aware of neglected dogs on the property, which is what indefinitely led to the rescue.

Donna, the property owner, had been left with animals after her husband died in the summer of 2014 after a long illness, and everything at the property went into disarray. “Her husband kept her isolated,” Forster said.

Donna’s husband had been breeding German shepherds and owned roughly 21 horses. The widow reached out because she needed homes for two of the dogs who had been severely neglected. When Forster did a courtesy call to check on the dogs and take photos, she had no idea she would find an animal hoarding situation in the process. However, the animals did have food, water and shelter, as required by Arizona law.

Due to the horrible conditions, Houlihan accompanied Forster on a subsequent visit to document the animals. She reached out to Underwood, a longtime volunteer with Saving Paws, for his assistance.


Initially, the owner wanted to sell the horses, which were mainly Arabians and quarter horses. “But the market was saturated at the time,” Forster said. “Everyone was trying to get her to understand that the horses didn’t have the value that she originally thought.”

The horses had lived in a terrible environment, and were riddled with awful fly bites, and they had not received any general care. They were not let out of their stalls, had not been exercised, and were denied hoof care, vet care and basic grooming. Although some of the horses were worth money on paper, most were not marketable because they had not been trained and were in bad condition.

Volunteers helped to clean the property, because the owner was facing code violation fines from the city for the manure problem, according to Forster.

Neighbors worked with Underwood and rented a tractor to help remove the impacted manure in the stalls and then fill them with sand. “Four of us rallied together to help clean up the property and worked with the owner to figure out which horses she’d be willing to let go,” Underwood stated. Eventually, all but a handful of horses found new homes or rescue centers. The rest remained with Donna.


Underwood found a sanctuary to take Monty. Donna was willing to let the 8-year-old registered Arabian go only because he had a club foot. Monty had a tendency to hide in the dark corner of his stall and poke his head out. First, his rescuers had to train him to get him out of his stall and off the property.

The more time Underwood spent with Monty, the more they connected. Underwood was gaining his trust. “He eventually let me brush him, so he was eager to learn and eager for a bond,” Underwood said.


“I knew it would be a lot of work to get him halter trained,” Underwood added. “I liked the challenge, and I could see that he needed someone. He needed an advocate, so we went with it. My wife grew up showing Arabs and she really bonded with him too.”

However, Monty was definitely a challenge, so Underwood hired a horse trainer.

Monty was frightened when Underwood and the trainer began to work with him. “Because he didn’t know how to run away, his way to remove himself from pressure was to throw himself on the ground,” Underwood said. This is quite uncommon for a horse as you might imagine.


It took two months in the fall of 2014 to get him halter trained and loaded into a trailer. “The more we worked with him, we knew he would be part of the family,” Underwood said. “We couldn’t let him go.”

Underwood adopted Monty and eventually moved to Colorado, along with their other horses. They started working with a vet who specializes in podiatry for horses, and Monty is getting stronger every day.

“To this day he follows me around everywhere,” Underwood said. “I’m always trying to teach him something new.”

Monty is very curious and always wants to meet everyone. He buddies up with all the animals but his favorite is Herman, the rescued mule. “Monty is our big puppy dog,” Underwood said. “When people come over, he’s first at the gate to meet them. We take him for walks around the neighborhood. He likes that.”


Although not physically abused, Monty was severely neglected, but he has learned to trust and is now extremely loyal. “Sometimes a rescued animal might take more work, but they are a lot more rewarding,” Underwood said. “Coming from neglect is more proof that these animals can forgive.”

To help Saving Paws Rescue, AZ continue the work it does saving animals, consider donating here.

Here is another video of Monty in the spring snow at his new home in Colorado: